The opening with Ellen sitting on Simon’s lap was wierd but I guess they did it for the laugh. I didn’t laugh. We’re down to 8 girls and the first one was Katie Steven’s.
* = Just OK
** = Not Bad
*** = Good
**** = Very Good
***** = Top 12 Material
Katie Stevens: ** Started flat. Too low for her. Too flat. Was waiting for something to happen and nothing did. Was too karaoke for me.
Siobhan Magnus: **** Very nice; loved her tone; and she took the song somewhere and made it her own.
Lacey Brown: *** Unique voice; in tune; interesting to me for the first time.
Katelyn Epperly: ** Didn’t move me, thrill me, or kill me. Sorry. The song was all over the place and it sounded like a lounge act.
Did Benami: *** She surprised me this week. Again, she has a unique voice. Good for some kind of genre. Maybe old dtyle. She was in tune but kind of just so so as it went on.
Paige Miles: * A big disappointment. She was flat at times and I don’t want to type anymore.
Crystal Bowersox: ***** Gave her 5 stars. That was terrific. Reminds a little of a mellower Janis Joplin. lol.
Lilly Scott: * I almost fell to pieces when she started the song. lol. OUCH! She may go home. Sorry.
Going home tomorrow.
Paige Miles and Katelyn Epperly.