Tonight, March 2nd, 2010 featured the guys. There are 2 more guys and 2 more gals going home on Thursday. I hope I am not too disappointed. How about you? I always write my comments down before the song is over and it was uncanny to me how close I came to what the judges said. Also, Simon said at the beginning he thought the girls last week were a smidge better than the guys. I disagree.
Please your thoughts and pick 2 guys you think are going home. Good luck.
* = Just OK
** = Not Bad
*** = Good
**** = Very Good
***** = Top 12 Material
Michael Lynch: **** I think he did an excellent job. It was in tune, a good song and he did well. Just a little to cocky at this point for me.
John Park: ** Didn’t do it for me. My mind drifted to what I was going to get at the grocery store tomorrow and started a grocery list.
Casey James: *** The third star was for the guitar playing. As for his singing and the song, fagettabotit.
Todrick Hall: ** sry. At this point, these guys should be really trying harder. I bit my fingernail and he didn’t WOW me.
Jermaine Sellers: *** He do just OK. He’s got nice pitch and stage presence.
Andrew Garcia: ** He seems to be going backward. I went from really liking him to second guessing myself. He had bad pitch problems and he was just not the Andrew I heard the day of his audition.
Aaron Kelly: ** What’s going on? He surprised me as well. I am starting to agree with Simon for what he said at the beginning of the show. This was just awful and so was his vibrato. Ugh!!
Tim Urban: ** A little better but still off key and I guess maybe the girls watching are swooning.
Lee Dewyze: ** Sounded a bit like Sting in the beginning. But then made a left turn somewhere. Sry.
Best of the night… Michael Lynch and that was it for me.
Guys Going home? I think Aaron Kelly and Tim Urban.
Ho-hum…..tonight’s show was about as exciting as watching wallpaper dry. And no wonder – those judges have the guys confused….”make it your own” – and when they do, the judges jump them for not sticking with the original song. I agree with Kieto – Michael was by far the best and the rest? Very unforgettable for me. I really don’t care who goes home, but I don’t think it will be Aaron or Tim (who was a little better tonight).
My pick to exit is John Park and Jermaine Sellers.
The ones I thought improved are:Mike Lynche, John Park, Alex Lambert, Todrick Hall, Jermaine Sellers, Aaron Kelly, and Tim Urban. Now, that doesn’t mean I thought they were good! My stars would be:
Mike L ****
John P *** song suited him
Casey ** his guitar is excellent but his voice isn’t
Alex **- It WAS better but last week I gave him * !
Todrick **
Jermaine **
Andrew ** disappointed again
Aaron ** 1st half of song was better than the 2nd. too much falsetto
Tim Urban **-
Lee Dewyze *** one of the most consistent
Looking at my stars, maybe I’m being too critical
To go home? Alex and Jermaine (If it isn’t Alex, it should be Tim)
Mike was the best, second best Lee.